Is Taylor Swift a scam? Decode the notes in their songs

Let us clarify one thing: when it comes to Taylor Swift, the woman cannot take a step without keeping the world up a flip glass for her love life. Separations, make -ups and everything in between – Taylor's love life is basically an open book (or more precisely an open album). While the world was busy analyzing their exen, cheating them, manipulating and generally confused, there is a question that we have to ask: Is Taylor Swift the fraudster? Yes, you heard that right.

She is always broken her heart, right? The sweet girl with doeäugigen whose friends broke her heart. But wait – what if Taylor's texts are not just about being cheated? What if you admit a moral behavior herself? Cue the gasp. Over the years, two specific scandals have triggered great rumors that Taylor could have exceeded some lines themselves: the entire drama of Calvin Harris and Tom Hiddleston and recently the Joe Alwyn and the Matty Healy chaos. So, are Taylor's texts just a beautifully woven network of fiction … or sings about her own chaotic reality?

Let us collapse. Spoiler Alert: We dive into your own songs for the clues. So snap at you. You could simply rethink who the “villain” is in their love stories.

Photo credits: Sjdavidl from Wikimedia Commons

Calvin Harris, Tom Hiddleston and the fastest rebound of all time

Let's return to 2016 when Taylor was with Calvin Harris and the whole world was obsessed with her relationship. Everything seemed to be fine. Really perfect. But then it ended as quickly as it started. In May 2016, boom, they were ready. The separation seemed to be friendly enough at first, but then – and I mean – saw the world horrified (or maybe just fascination?) When Taylor continued immediately.

Less than two weeks after the separation, Taylor already hung around with Tom Hiddleston on the beaches, parties and basically in every corner of the tabloid. We speak of a “vertebral romance” that took about five minutes. But here is the kicker: the timeline? It didn't add up. Was Taylor already emotionally involved with Tom before she separated from Calvin? Did she secretly sent him during her relationship with Calvin? The questions were endless and the rumors? Sharp.

While Taylor and Calvin played it cool in public, their separation certainly seemed one of those in whom the “other person” was already in the picture, but nobody wanted to admit it. We may never know if she actually cheated, but the timing has not helped her to have the case. Some fans even speculated that Taylor was emotionally checked out of their relationship with Calvin, which could explain the quick rebound. But hey, a girl has to live, right?

Photo credits: Ronald Woan von Wikimedia Commons

Joe Alwyn, Matty Healy and the most unpleasant love triangle ever

In April 2023 the world stopped for Swifties. The news finally came that Taylor and Joe Alwyn, their six -year -old friend, were separated. It was shocking and confusing for the public, but the fans didn't have to wait to see Taylor's next relationship after the separation. Enter: Matty Healy, lead singer of 1975. The fans quickly connected the points, and rumors flew that Taylor and Matty were more than just friendly staff. In fact, some suggested that Matty was the reason for her separation with Joe.

It gets really juicy here: just a few weeks after their separation with Joe, Taylor and Matty appeared in the same circles. Regardless of whether it was dealing with music events or random meeting points, people asked: “Did Taylor and Matty joined? Did Joe emotionally cheat on him?” Now we have no concrete evidence (because obviously), but when the rumors have been hit, things became complicated. Did Taylor cheat emotionally? Or was it just a case of two people who spent time together and the press blow everything disproportionately? Timing alone raised the eyebrows.

But wait – it gets even more fascinating here. Taylor, the lyrical genius she is, might have given us a hint in one of her songs. Did you hear “guilty as a sin” by the department for tortured poets? Yes, the fans became wild about this, and it is not difficult to understand why.

Photo credits: Ronald Woan von Wikimedia Commons

“Guilty as sin” – a commitment to fraud or just an evil imagination?

Okay, let's talk about “guilty as sin”. The title alone is basically a confession. When someone says, “I guilty like sin”, put your hand on his heart and go: “Yes, I did it.” Now the song does not say directly: “I cheated Joe with Matty”, but the texts safely as [censored] Space for interpretation.

“I keep these longings in small letters in a vault …

These deadly fantasies give way to the tedious breath

We have already done it in my head with me. “

The texts convey emotional infidelity – the way in which someone is emotionally or mentally involved with someone else, even if the physical limits are not exceeded. It is like imagining someone else while they are with someone – it's not real, but it feels real in your head. And this mental space is just as consuming, if not more than physical acts. In this sense, there is also a layer of guilt, the feeling that she knows that these thoughts are dangerous or forbidden. She doesn't react physically to her, but it is already mentally there.

Photo credits: Vixy13 From Wikimedia Commons

But here is: emotional fraud is still cheating. And in combination with the timeline of their relationship, the texts seem to scream after the Joe: “I might have crossed a line.” We do not know whether she is literally cheated, but the song definitely catches the feeling of catching something that you know that you shouldn't be, and it somehow likes it. (This is called emotional infidelity, my friends.)

So what admits Taylor here? Is that your confession about Matty? Perhaps. Or maybe it's just a creative view of the idea of ​​doing something bad, but still enjoying the rush. In any case, it is a damn song, and it makes us ask: “Is it guilty or just misunderstood?”

Photo credits: Paolo V of Wikimedia Commons

What does that mean?

Now let's appear again and look at the overall picture. Is Taylor Swift a scam? The truth is, we can't really know. She is not outside with a flag on which “I cheated” (obviously), but the timing of these two main relationships – Calvin Harris to Tom Hiddleston and Joe Alwyn to Matty Healy – makes it difficult to ignore that there have been some emotional complications before the official separation.

In both cases, Taylor's texts indicate guilt, betrayal and maybe a little moral ambiguity. She is not shy to write songs that explore the untidy parts of relationships. Regardless of whether it is the thrill of an illegal connection or the regret of emotional scattering, Taylor is known to transform her personal experiences into catchy, urgent hymns, which ask us all: “Was it really the one who was cheated … Or did she fraud?”

Photo credits: Sally-Marie Böhm von Wikimedia Commons

Ultimately, Taylor is a master in whom she creates layers in her music and whether you confess your own defects or only make stories to entertain, we are all for it. And until she decides to actually spill the tea for her relationships, we will simply play the installment game. After all, this is the Swiftie path.

And who knows? Maybe the next album will finally give us some answers. Or maybe it just lets us ask more. In any case, we are all guilty of sin because we tried to decipher everything.