The right -wing expert burdens Nagi Maehashi and Brooke Bellamys Plagiatskandal

If you have Was near social media last week, you have Probably heard of the continued drama between the founder Nagi Maehashi and the influencer Brooke Bellamy, who are baked well in a fight for a fan favorite bakery: caramel disc.

Many have wondered whether their feud will play in court and whether a recipe can really be plagued.

Ground zero

On April 29, Nagi went to social media, to be better known as Brooki Bakehouse, to plagger her caramel slice and baklava recipes and publish pictures next to each other to compare your website with the comparison of your website Brooke's New cookbook, Bake with Brooki.

“I I have nothing to get when you say, but it would let me be silent. Because I am Not the only one,” she Formed the post that won over 140,000 likes. “TO I, the similarities are so specific and detailed that it feels incorrect.” She wrote.

“I'M Speaking because it stays still protects this type of behavior. The benefit of plagued recipes is unethical, even if not a copyright infringement, and It is A slap in the face for every author who does the hard work to create original content instead of cutting corners.” Nagi added that she contacted Penguin Random House Australia in December 2024, And was disappointed with her lack of action.

How did Brooke react?

Brooke quickly published an explanation in which she had doubled her decision to publish the recipes and claimed she had created her four years before Nagi. “I Don't copy others People Recipes. How many bakers do I get inspired by the classicsbut the Creations they see Brooki Bakehouse Reflecting mine own Experience, taste and passion for baking, born of countless hours of my childhood that was spent in my home kitchen with mother.” She wrote.

“W.Hile Back has scope for creativity, a large part of it is a precise science and necessarily formula. Many recipes have to share joint steps and measuresIf She notShe simply not work.“

“IIn March 2020, Recipetin Eats published a recipe for caramel slices. It uses the same ingredients as my recipe that I have been producing and selling for four years.” She claimed. Brooke added that she had offered to remove the two recipes from future reprints of her book “to prevent further aggravatioN “, Quote “great respect” For Nagi.

What's next?

Instagram

Lawyer Mark Metzeling spoke to Lawyers weekly About the drama that explains this Nagis Claims must not be in court.

“A List of ingredients for a recipe can compare To a data record in which this elements tip be replaced/changed to produce the same good,” he said. “It is It is therefore unlikely that a list of ingredients would be enforceable. Similarly, a written description of the method for the production of an element is probably regarded as unoriginal, since it only describes a known process.”

He added that recipes such as Caramel Slice and Baklava have been universal and have been around for decades that they are not protected by copyright if it contains a unique turn that has not yet been carried out.

Instagram

Mark mentioned if Brooke had copied Nagis He could write your writing style Be classified Copyright. “However, the main protection is to carry out how a recipe is expressed (the combination of writing, photos, videos etc.). If the presentation of the recipe over the ingredients and the back method of ordinary baked goods replicates a significant part of the original layout and the presentation, lawyers could have a case. “

He added that Brooke could defend Nagis Allegations by proof that they Had created the recipe from scratch. “IF A person has developed the same recipe for the production of a court as another person and expressed it in a very similar or identical way. This person would not violate copyright if she could show that she developed the recipe completely independently of one another.” he said.

“IF Brooki can show an independent creation of your recipePresent Recipe development, and has expressed Your ideas regardless of Nagi, as well as Show originality in the recipe, it should be able to defend itself Nagis Claims. “

Take sides

Instagram

Since Nagis Bombshell Post, Brooke was dropped as an ambassador for the academy for enterprising Girl, And was the victim of a wave of online hatred.

“I knowledge I have made serious allegations … but that does not justify the personal attacks I have Seen online against Brooke Bellamy,” Nagi said in an open video that was posted on her Instagram. “I don't support it And I am Ask them to stop. “

The popular American Baker Sally McKenney also performed and claimed that her 2019 recipe, “The best vanilla cake I have Ever had“,”, was plagued by Brooke.