Laura Loomer aims at Trump's choice for the general surgeon, while Kennedy pushes back

The selection of Dr. Casey Means of President Trump, a wellness specialist and author trained by Stanford, when his next general surgeon on Thursday, there was a strong debate on whether someone who is not a practicing doctor should serve as the highest doctor in the nation.

Laura Loomer, the right -wing extremist activist, who influenced Mr. Trump so much that more than half a dozen national security officers were released on her advice, was created as a vocalist. So also Nicole Shanahan, Minister of Health Robert F. Kennedy Jr.'s former running colleague, who described the election as “very strange”.

Dr. Means a close ally of Mr. Kennedy, who was trained as a surgeon in otolaryngology – ear, nose, nose and throat medicine – after four years, left her surgical stay after four years to practice “functional medicine”, which focuses on the causes of the disease. She said she was disillusioned by the medical facility and came to the conclusion that it was not patient.

Mrs. Loomer ridiculed Dr. Means on Thursday on social media and called it a “total crack pot” that uses “mushrooms as” plant medicine “and speaks with trees!” And “doesn't even have an active medical license.” Ms. Loomer published extracts by Dr. Messings weekly newsletter in which Dr. means that recipes, product recommendations and other topics, including “Mindset shifts and habits”, consider.

Mr. Kennedy pushed back hard with a long post and called the criticism as “absurd”, while Mr. Trump said reporters that he said Dr. Medium did not know, but had selected it because “Bobby was fantastic”.

The brother of Dr. Means, Calley Means, a advisor to the White House for Health Questions and former lobbyist from the food industry, defended his sister in an interview.

“Casey inspired millions of Americans and is a threat to the status quo because she left the medical system, not anyway,” said Mr. Means.

He added that the family was shocked when she left her stay, “but she had a clear moral insight that her patients did not get better.”

According to the Federal Law, the general surgeon monitors the commissioned corps of the US health service, the uniformed service that works on the front of public health.

There are only two requirements for the job: The candidate must be a member of the corps (normally the president simply appoints a candidate before he or she takes over) and must have “special training or significant experience in public health programs”.

Dr. David A. Kessler, a former head of the Food and Drug Administration, who was also Dean of Medical Faculties in Yale and the University of California in San Francisco, said in an interview that legitimate reasons, Dr. To criticize the means and not for a current medical license.

The main question, said Dr. Kessler is whether a general surgeon is “well trained” in medicine. If Dr. Means to end four years of residence, he said: “She is very well trained.”

Large medical groups were largely silent about the appointment. Neither the American Medical Association nor the American Public Health Association have published explanations. But Arthur L. Caplan, a prominent medical ethicist at New York University, described the appointment as “irresponsible”.

“The appointment of Casey means that a non-practicing doctor who has spent for years unpaved” health interventions “means a general surgeon who blames a marginal practitioner of the unproven functional medicine to clarify the American population about their health and illness challenges,” wrote Dr. Caplan in an email.

Dr. Caplan found that Mr. Kennedy has asked to be spouse -controlled with vaccines, and said that health secretary should apply the same scientific accuracy to the type of functional and alternative appeal. Dr. “Without data, it is comparable to your Nevark Airport without a radio or radio,” he wrote.

The mean values ​​are both media-promoted wellness entrepreneurs. Calley Means is the founder of Truemed, a startup that enables tax -free expenses for nutritional supplements, exercise and healthy food. Casey Means is the founder of Levels, a company that offers subscribers to portable glucose monitors to pursue their health.

Her hug of holistic therapies has drawn some eyelets in the press. Rolling Stone called her a “Woo-Wooo wellness influencer”.

Dr. Last year means that she and her brother appeared in Tucker Carlson's show to promote her diet and self-help book “Good Energy”, which argues that metabolic dysfunction is the root of chronic disease epidemic.

Mr. Kennedy said about X that Dr. My ability to inspire the Americans, to rethink our health system, “an existential threat to the status quo interests that benefit from illness”. In an interview with Fox News, he said that she had “galvanized” his movement “Make America Healthy”.

Like Mr. Kennedy, Dr. Means repeatedly said that America is in the middle of a chronic disease crisis. It has pointed out rising rates of infertility, obesity, diabetes, depression and other conditions as evidence. Just like Mr. Kennedy, she suggested that environmental toxins and the food system are to blame.

Mr. Trump's appointment by Dr. Means was a surprise. He announced it on Wednesday after he had withdrawn the nomination of his previous election, Dr. Janette Nesheiwat, who was to be released on Thursday before the Senate Health Committee.

Dr. Nesheiwat, an urgent nursing doctor and former commentator for Fox News, is the sister -in -law of Michael Waltz, who acted as a National Security Adviser by Mr. Trump until last week. She had criticized that she was less of her references than in the areas. Ms. Loomer complained that Dr. Nesheiwat is not “ideologically oriented” with the president.

The general surgeon has no real authority to determine politics. The power of the job lies in the platform and in the reports of the general surgeon. The pioneering report on Tobacco from 1964 led to warning discs for cigarette packages. Dr. C. Everett Koop, one of the most famous surgeons in the country, used the office to enter patients with AIDS at a time when his Republicans ignored the illness.

Dr. Vivek Murthy, who acted as a general surgeon in the Obama and Biden administrations, spoke about loneliness and mental health.

Dr. David Perlmutter, an ally of Dr. Means, whose work focuses on the interface of nutrition and neurological disorders, said that the most important quality for every general surgeon is the ability to convey to the public.

Dr. means that he said: