close
close
Man who killed the alienated woman, her 2 youthful sons who are supposed to be executed

Man who killed the alienated woman, her 2 youthful sons who are supposed to be executed

by

The three -time murder, which was committed by Tennessee Death Row occupant Oscar Franklin Smith, proves one thing, according to a detective who has dealt with the decades of decades: “True bad.”

The 75-year-old Smith is to be executed by fatal injection for murder on his alienated wife, 35-year-old Judith Robirds Smith and her sons, 13-year-old Jason Burnett and 16-year-old Chad Burnett. The three were murdered in their house in Nashville.

“The boys were brutalized,” said Detective Pat Postiglione, detective of the Metro Nashville Police Department, Tennessean, part of the USA Today Network, in 2022. “

Smith's lawyer Kelley Henry told USA Today that Smith always kept his innocence and that the past two weeks have been hard for him because the correction officers moved him to a small cell near the direction of execution.

“This type of isolation is incredibly traumatizing. It is also unnecessary,” she told USA. “In the two weeks before the execution, there have never been difficulties in Tennesse's death cell.”

When the execution approaches, USA Today looks back on the crime that Smith is and who his victims were.

What was Oscar Franklin Smith convicted?

On the night of October 1, 1989, a police dispatcher from Nashville replied a 911 call of 13-year-old Jason Burnett, who managed to scream: “Help me!” When he hears his brother's mutilated voice: “Frank, no! God help me,” says court files.

After the hectic call, police officers responded to the house, said they had seen nothing unusual and circling the call to a false alarm, the court files said. But both boys and their mother had been murdered inside.

Fifteen hours after the 911 call, an 8-year-old relative found the three corpses in the house, and her throat meandering ears.

Judith Robirds Smith also had a gunshot wound on the left arm and her neck and, according to Tennessean, was stabbed several times. Jason, an eighth grader, was on the side of the bed where his mother was.

Chad, a high school in the second year, was located in a blood pool in the back in the kitchen, according to court files. He had been shot through his left eye, upper chest and shoulder and had been stabbed several times with a sharp, needle -like weapon and a knife

Smith was asked by the police the next day. They saw his reaction to the news of the murder of his alienated family as a red flag.

“When they told him, he showed no emotions,” the former deputy district attorney of Davidson County, Tom Thurman, told Tennessean.

What led to the murders of mother, 2 sons?

Smith had threatened his alienated wife several times before he had committed the murders, and a month earlier she had connected, raped and threatened to kill her, said court files.

Smith also called her several times in the Waffle House in which she worked, threatened to kill her, and even told her father that he would kill his daughter, according to court records.

“Smith said to Judy's father:” You say Judy that I played with children's gloves with her, but now my gloves are going. “Another time he said that he would kill Judy if she ever left him,” said the public prosecutor's office in court files.

On several occasions, Smith should have offered money to everyone who is willing to kill his alienated woman.

Smith had two young children from an earlier marriage, while Chad and Jason Judy Smith's sons were from an earlier marriage.

When the couple married in 1985, their own two boys had it. But until June 1989 they separated and there was a custody battle for the twins.

Teresa Zastrow, Judy Smith's sister, told the police that Smith had misused her sister several times. Don Robirds, Judy's father, told Tennessean that Judy asked him and his wife in 1988 to sign a note that was told to her husband where she was.

“Once she came into the house and said she had to have a signed newspaper before she went home,” said Robirds. “My wife had to sign the newspaper. That was the only true indication that Judy had ever given us.”

Smith tries to avoid the death penalty

Smith's execution date was previously planned three times as the oldest inmate in Tennesse's death cell, but was delayed for various reasons. If the execution progresses this time, Smith will be the first inmate to be carried out in Tennessee this year since 2020 and 19th in the United States.

The last time Smith was executed was in 2022 when the execution was discontinued just an hour before the connection.

At that time, the Republican governor Bill Lee gave a temporary postponement due to an supervision of the fatal injection protocol of the state. The supervision ultimately led to a three -year moratorium for executions in Tennessee, an independent audit and a new protocol.

After the end of this moratorium, Smith is said to be the first execution of the state since 2020, but his defenders, together with eight other inmates, submitted a lawsuit to challenge the new protocol from Tennessee.

“We have real and justified concerns that the new protocol, which prompted even fewer protective measures than the last-our clients to experience the terror, pain and suffering that comes from the polling act required in the protocol,” said lawyer Amy Harwell in a letter to Lee in April.

Her concerns focus on the state of Tennessee, which used the drug pentobarbital, from which Harwell can take to 20 minutes in the letter as long as the inmate could remain aware and experience what it described as “chemical waterboarding”.

The state authorities argue that the execution method is constitutional and effective.

On Tuesday, Lee rejected Smith's request to mercy in which the execution took place.

Contribution: Kelly Puente, Nashville Tennessean and Natalie Neysa Alund, USA Today

Fernando Cervantes Jr. is a trendy news reporter for USA Today. Reach it at fernando.cervantes@gannett.com and follow it on x @fernn_cerv_.

Leave a Comment